401k Investment Fiduciary

3(21) vs. 3(38) Fiduciary: What 401(k) and 403(b) Plan Sponsors Need to Know

When you sponsor a 401(k) or 403(b) plan, someone has to choose the investment menu, watch it over time, and make changes when a fund no longer fits. ERISA, the federal law that governs most private-sector retirement plans, treats that work as a fiduciary duty. Many employers bring in outside help, and two terms come up quickly: a “3(21)” fiduciary and a “3(38)” fiduciary.

The numbers refer to sections of ERISA. The difference between them comes down to one question: who has the final say on the plan’s investments? This guide explains both roles, what stays with you either way, and how to think through which arrangement fits your plan.

The short answer

  • A 3(21) investment fiduciary gives investment advice and recommendations. Your plan committee still makes the decisions.
  • A 3(38) investment manager has discretion to select, monitor, and replace the plan’s investments, within the limits you set when you appoint it.
  • In both cases, you keep the duty to prudently select and monitor the fiduciary you hire, and to make sure the fees are reasonable. Neither arrangement removes all of your fiduciary responsibility.

What is a 3(21) fiduciary?

ERISA section 3(21)(A) defines who is a fiduciary. Among other things, a person is a fiduciary to the extent they exercise discretionary authority or control over plan management or plan assets, or render investment advice for a fee. An advisor who provides investment advice to your plan for compensation is generally called a “3(21) fiduciary” for that reason.

In a typical 3(21) arrangement, the advisor:

  • Helps the committee draft or update the investment policy statement.
  • Reviews the fund lineup against that policy and reports on it, often quarterly.
  • Recommends funds to add, keep on watch, or replace.

The committee reviews those recommendations and decides. Because the advisor is a fiduciary for the advice it gives, it shares responsibility for that advice. But the decision, and responsibility for the decision, stays with the plan’s fiduciaries. If the committee doesn’t act on a recommendation, or acts without documenting why, that is on the committee.

What is a 3(38) fiduciary?

ERISA section 3(38) defines an “investment manager.” To qualify, the manager must have the power to manage, acquire, or dispose of plan assets; must be a registered investment adviser, a bank, or a qualifying insurance company; and must acknowledge in writing that it is a fiduciary with respect to the plan.

When a named fiduciary properly appoints a 3(38) investment manager, the manager makes the investment decisions it was appointed to make. It selects the funds, monitors them, and replaces them when they no longer meet the investment policy, without waiting for committee approval. ERISA section 405(d) provides that plan trustees are not liable for the investment manager’s acts or omissions, and the Department of Labor explains that an employer that appoints a qualifying investment manager “is not liable for the individual investment decisions of that manager.”

That relief has limits, which is the part many sponsors miss.

What you keep either way

The DOL’s guide for employers, Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities, says the employer “is responsible for the selection of the manager” and “is required to monitor the manager periodically.” Hiring a fiduciary is itself a fiduciary act. Whichever model you choose, your plan’s fiduciaries keep these responsibilities:

  • Prudently selecting the advisor or manager, with a documented process (credentials, services, fees, and how they compare with alternatives).
  • Monitoring the advisor or manager over time and replacing it if needed.
  • Making sure the plan’s fees are reasonable for the services received. Service providers’ 408(b)(2) disclosures describe their fiduciary status and compensation; see our guide to 408(b)(2) and 404(a)(5) fee disclosures.
  • Setting the scope of the engagement in writing, including what the manager can and can’t do.
  • Plan administration duties, such as Form 5500 filings, participant notices, timely deposit of contributions, and following the plan document, unless some are assigned to a 3(16) administrator.
  • Co-fiduciary exposure. ERISA section 405(a) can make a fiduciary liable for another fiduciary’s breach if it knowingly participates in it, enables it, or knows about it and doesn’t take reasonable steps to fix it.

3(21) vs. 3(38) at a glance

3(21) investment fiduciary 3(38) investment manager
Who makes investment decisions Plan committee, based on the advisor’s recommendations The investment manager, within its written appointment
ERISA source Section 3(21)(A): fiduciary, including investment advice for a fee Section 3(38): investment manager; appointed under section 402(c)(3)
Who must it be Any person providing fiduciary investment advice Registered investment adviser, bank, or qualifying insurance company that acknowledges fiduciary status in writing
Fund selection and replacement Advisor recommends; committee approves and implements Manager selects and replaces funds
Responsibility for investment decisions Shared: advisor for its advice, committee for its decisions Manager, for the decisions it makes
What the sponsor keeps Investment decisions, plus selecting and monitoring the advisor Selecting and monitoring the manager, fees, and scope of the appointment
Committee time on investments More: review and vote on recommendations Less: oversight of the manager’s process and results
Control over the fund menu Higher Lower; the manager decides within the policy

Where 3(16) fits

A 3(16) fiduciary is different. ERISA section 3(16)(A) defines the “plan administrator.” An outside 3(16) administrator can take on administrative duties such as signing the Form 5500, approving distributions and loans, and handling required notices, depending on the agreement. It doesn’t pick investments. Some sponsors combine a 3(16) administrator with a 3(21) or 3(38) investment fiduciary, and the same rule applies: you prudently select and monitor it. For more, see should we outsource our 3(16) admin services.

How to choose between a 3(21) and a 3(38)

Neither model is right for every plan. These questions can help your committee decide:

How much time and expertise does your committee have?

A 3(21) arrangement works when the committee meets regularly, understands the investment policy, and is willing to review and act on recommendations. If meetings are hard to schedule or decisions tend to stall, a 3(38) arrangement moves those decisions to the manager.

How much control do you want over the fund menu?

Some committees want a say in every fund change, for example to limit disruption for employees or to keep a fund that participants know. With a 3(38), you set the investment policy and limits, but the manager decides within them.

How well documented is your current process?

Under either model, documentation matters. Committee minutes, an investment policy statement, and records of how you selected and monitor your advisor show that the plan followed a prudent process. If your committee’s records are thin, that may influence how much you want to keep in-house. Our article on investment committee fiduciary responsibilities covers the basics.

What does each option cost, and what do you get?

Compare services, not only price. Ask each provider for its 408(b)(2) disclosure, confirm whether it is acting as a 3(21) or 3(38) fiduciary, and benchmark the total cost against similar plans. See how often to benchmark your 401(k) plan fees.

What does the agreement actually say?

Titles vary in the industry, so read the contract. Confirm which section of ERISA the provider acknowledges, which investments are in scope, whether it covers the qualified default investment alternative, how and when it reports to the committee, and how either side can end the arrangement.

Questions to ask a prospective investment fiduciary

  1. Will you acknowledge your fiduciary status in writing, and under which ERISA section?
  2. Which plan investments are within your scope?
  3. How do you select, monitor, and replace funds, and how is that tied to our investment policy statement?
  4. What will you report to our committee, and how often?
  5. How are you paid, directly and indirectly, and how does that appear in your 408(b)(2) disclosure?
  6. What happens to the fund lineup and our records if we end the engagement?

Where we fit

Retirement Partners of California works with employers on 401(k), 403(b), and deferred compensation plans as an advisor with a fiduciary standard.

Through LPL Financial, we offer both 3(21) and 3(38) investment fiduciary services, and each plan sponsor chooses the arrangement that fits their plan.

FAQs

What is a 3(21) fiduciary?

An advisor who provides investment advice to a retirement plan for a fee and is a fiduciary for that advice under ERISA section 3(21)(A). The plan committee keeps the final decision on investments.

What is a 3(38) fiduciary?

An investment manager, as defined in ERISA section 3(38), that has discretion to select, monitor, and replace plan investments. It must be a registered investment adviser, a bank, or a qualifying insurance company and must acknowledge its fiduciary status in writing.

Does a 3(38) remove all fiduciary liability?

No. A properly appointed 3(38) investment manager is responsible for the investment decisions it makes, but the plan sponsor remains responsible for prudently selecting and monitoring the manager, making sure fees are reasonable, and its other fiduciary duties.

What is the difference between a 3(21) and a 3(38) fiduciary?

Discretion. A 3(21) advises, and the plan committee decides. A 3(38) decides, within the authority you give it, and the committee oversees the manager.

Is a 3(21) a co-fiduciary?

Often, yes. A 3(21) advisor is a fiduciary for the advice it gives, alongside the plan’s other fiduciaries. ERISA’s co-fiduciary rules can make any fiduciary liable for another’s breach if it participates in, enables, or fails to address it.

What is a 3(16) fiduciary?

A plan administrator under ERISA section 3(16)(A). An outside 3(16) can take on administrative duties such as signing the Form 5500 and approving distributions, depending on the agreement. It doesn’t manage investments.

Do these roles apply to 403(b) plans?

Yes, for 403(b) plans that are subject to ERISA. Many governmental and church plans are not subject to ERISA, so check with your ERISA counsel.

Want to talk through your plan’s fiduciary setup?

If you’re not sure who is responsible for your plan’s investment decisions today, or whether your current arrangement still fits, we can help you review it. We’ll walk through your agreements, disclosures, and committee process with you. Explore our services for plan sponsors.

Disclosures, Sources, and Footnotes

This information was developed as a general guide to educate plan sponsors, but is not intended as authoritative guidance or tax or legal advice. Each plan has unique requirements, and you should consult your attorney or tax advisor for guidance on your specific situation. In no way does advisor assure that, by using the information provided, plan sponsor will be in compliance with ERISA regulations.