Cash Balance Plans: Larger Tax Deductions and Increased Retirement Savings

Our 401(k) Advisory Services

How Can Cash Balance Plans Increase Our Tax Deductions?

401k advisor cash balanceA Cash Balance plan is a type of retirement plan that belongs to the same general class of plans known as “Qualified Plans.” A 401(k) is a qualified plan which means this plan “qualifies” for tax deferral and creditor protection under ERISA.

In a Cash Balance Plan each participant has their own account. The account grows annually in two ways:

  1. Contributions from employer
  2. An interest credit – this is guaranteed rather than being dependent on the plan’s investment performance.

Many owners of businesses and partners are looking for larger tax deductions and accelerated retirement savings. Cash Balance Plans may be the perfect solution for them. The 2006 Pension Protection Act (PPA) and the Cash Balance regulations issued in 2010 and 2014 have made these qualified plans even more flexible and easier to administer, making them increasingly popular choice for successful business owners.

Common Questions About Cash Balance Plans

How Does a Cash Balance Plan Work?

A Cash Balance plan is a defined benefit plan that specifies both the contribution to be credited to each participant and the investment earnings to be credited based on those contributions. Each participant has their own account (similar to a 401(k) or profit sharing plan). These accounts are maintained by the plan actuary (don’t worry, this is someone part of our team) who generates annual participant statements.

Participant accounts grow annually in two ways:

  1. The company contribution: a percentage of pay or a flat dollar amount determined by a formula specified in the plan document
  2. An annual interest credit: This rate of return is guaranteed. It is independent of the plan’s investment performance. It changes each year but usually is equal to the yield on 30-year Treasury bonds.

When employees leave your company, they are eligible to receive the vested portion of their account balances.

How Much Can I Contribute to a Cash Balance Plan?

Cash Balance contributions are age-dependent. The older the participant, the higher the amount is. The reason for this difference is that an older person has fewer years to save toward the approximate $2.6 million lump sum that is allowed in a Cash Balance Plan.

Subject to IRS limits, the actual contribution is determined by a formula specified in the plan document. It can be either a percentage of pay or a flat dollar amount.

We are happy to run a calculation for you to let you know. Book a consultation.

What if We Want to Change Plan Contributions Each Year?

This is where it gets more technical but don’t worry, we’ll guide you. A Profit Sharing Plan allows for contributions to vary from year to year depending on profitability, but Cash Balance Plans must be amended in order to change contribution levels.

Employers can designate different contribution amounts for various participants, but there is a restriction on the frequency of amendments unless a valid economic reason exists.

  • For example, if a firm’s profits are not expected to support its Cash Balance Plan contribution, then the plan can be amended. Any reductions must be made before any employee works 1,000 hours during a plan year. For increases, the plan must be amended within two and a half months following the end of a plan year.

In addition, a Cash Balance Plan can also be frozen or terminated before an employee works 1,000 hours during a plan year.

Must Everyone Equally Participate in a Cash Balance Plan?

No. This is where plan design expertise is critical to success of the plan. Each participant can receive a different contribution amount from the employer. The amount can be a percentage of pay or a flat dollar amount.

What Are The Tax Advantages of a Cash Balance Plan?

Let’s be honest, tax deductions are hard to come by, especially those that directly reduce ordinary income dollar for dollar.

Contributions to Cash Balance Plans have the same tax effect as a deduction that reduces ordinary income dollar for dollar!

With combined Federal and State income tax rates as high as 45%, the tax savings from the contributions and the subsequent earnings on these contributions can be very significant.

  • Example: one single contribution of $130,000 earning 5% a year for 30 years, would be worth $561,852 at the end of 30 years. However, if the $130,000 had been taxed in the year contributed so that an “after tax” amount was invested, and if subsequent earnings on this contribution had also been taxed in each year (assuming the highest tax rates indicated above), then at the end of 30 years the total value would be only $162,937; 29% of the amount calculated above!

Cash Balance Plans are part of a group of plans called “qualified plans,” indicating their tax-favored status with the IRS. Tax advisors generally agree that these plans should be funded to their maximum before other tax-efficient strategies are explored.

In summary, contributing to a Cash Balance Plan can provide tremendous tax benefits. These benefits apply to both the amount contributed and the subsequent earnings on those contributions. Furthermore, the investment earnings on the contribution will compound, potentially enabling it to grow to a very significant amount.

Will a Cash Balance Plan Work For Me?

Many of our clients find Cash Balance an excellent way to increase contributions to their retirement accounts. In our vast experience with Cash Balance Plans, we have found that the following are typically good candidates:

  1. Partners or owners who desire to contribute more than $50,000 a year to their retirement accounts.
    Many professionals and entrepreneurs neglect their personal retirement savings while they’re building their practice or their company. They often have a need to catch up on years of retirement savings. Adding a Cash Balance Plan allows them to rapidly accelerate savings with pre-tax contributions as high as $100,000 to $260,000, depending on their age.
  2. Companies already contributing 3-4% to employees, or at least willing to do so.
    While Cash Balance Plans are often established for the benefit of key executives and other highly compensated employees, other employees benefit as well. The plan normally provides a minimum contribution between 5% and 7.5% of pay for staff in the Cash Balance Plan or a separate Profit Sharing 401(k) plan.
  3. Companies that have demonstrated consistent profit patterns.
    Because a Cash Balance Plan is a pension plan with required annual contributions, consistent cash flow and profit is very important.
  4. Partners or owners over 40 years of age who desire to “catch up” or accelerate their pension savings.
    Maximum amounts allowed in Cash Balance Plans are age-dependent. The older the participant, the faster they can accelerate their savings.

Can Cash Balance Plans Be Offered With Other Plans Like Our 401k?

Yes and most of the time they are. As an employer you can offer a combination of qualified retirement plans in order to produce a larger contribution amount (we will figure out the right plan for you, don’t worry). Just as a Profit Sharing feature can be added to a 401(k) plan, an employer can add a Cash Balance Plan as well. In fact, a 401(k) plan in combination with a Cash Balance Plan can be the ideal plan-design for many companies and partnerships.

Are Cash Balance Plans Considered a Qualified Plan?

Yes, a Cash Balance plan is an IRS-qualified plan, and all contributions to qualified plans are tax-deductible expenses. Like all qualified retirement plans, assets are protected from creditors.

Fun Fact: The first Cash Balance plan in the US was introduced of Bank of America in 1985. The Pension Protection Act (PPA) of 2006 affirmed the legality of Cash Balance plans and made the plans easier to administer. New IRS Cash Balance regulations in 2010 and 2014 expanded investment options, minimizing many funding issues and making the plans even more appealing to business owners and their employees.

Are Cash Balance Plans Protected From Creditors Like a 401(k)?

Yes and the DOL makes that very clear. Cash Balance plans are IRS-qualified retirement plans, and all qualified plan assets are protected from creditors in the event of bankruptcy. The anti-alienation provision of ERISA states that “each pension plan shall provide that benefits provided under the plan may not be assigned or alienated.” This means that the assets in a qualified plan are not available to creditors.

Since professionals and business owners often consider asset protection a premium it is very advantageous to accrue retirement savings in an asset-protected vehicle, like a qualified plan. These plans provide a means for business owners and partners to move assets from their businesses to a pension plan. Once in the qualified plan, these assets are then protected from creditors as a “nest egg” for retirement or to pass on to heirs.

How Do Deductions and Allocations Work for Partnerships?

Tax deductions for contributions made on behalf of non-partner employees are taken on the partnership tax return. Partners and owners take the tax deductions made on their behalf on their personal or corporate tax returns.

However, to be sure that the amount deducted for tax purposes by a partner as shown on Schedule K-1 is the same as the amount contributed on behalf of the partner, the partnership’s agreement must permit this method of allocation.

Keep in mind, most partnerships that adopt Cash Balance plans do not want the partner’s contributions allocated like most other firm expenses, in proportion to ownership. Either the partnership agreement or internal policy should assure that each partner is allocated an appropriate share of the plan’s cost.