If you sponsor a 401(k) or 403(b) plan, you are responsible for making sure the plan pays only reasonable fees for the services it receives. You can’t judge whether a fee is reasonable by looking at it alone. You need something to compare it with. That comparison is what retirement plan benchmarking is for.
This guide covers what 401(k) fee benchmarking is, why it matters under ERISA, what to compare, how often to do it, how to use your 408(b)(2) disclosures, and how to document the review so you can show the process you followed.
What is 401(k) fee benchmarking?
401(k) fee benchmarking is the process of comparing your plan’s costs and services with those of similar plans. A benchmarking review usually looks at plans of comparable size, measured by plan assets and number of participants, with a similar range of services.
The goal isn’t to find the lowest price. It’s to understand what your plan pays, what it gets in return, and whether the two line up. A plan that pays more than its peers may still be reasonable if it receives more services, and a lower-cost plan may be missing services its participants need.
Fee benchmarking is one part of broader retirement plan benchmarking, which can also cover investment performance, participation and deferral rates, plan design features and service quality. We cover those areas below.
Why plan sponsors benchmark retirement plan costs
ERISA requires plan fiduciaries to act prudently and solely in the interest of participants and beneficiaries, and to use plan assets only to provide benefits and pay reasonable plan expenses. ERISA section 408(b)(2) also requires that a plan’s service arrangements be reasonable and that no more than reasonable compensation be paid for the services.
The Department of Labor (DOL) has addressed this directly. In its publication Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities, the DOL says an employer should establish and follow a formal review process at reasonable intervals to decide whether to keep its current service providers or look for replacements. Its guide Understanding Retirement Plan Fees and Expenses says that after the initial selection, a plan’s fees and expenses should be monitored to determine whether they continue to be reasonable.
ERISA doesn’t prescribe a specific benchmarking method or report. But a documented benchmarking review is a common way for plan fiduciaries to show they compared fees with the market and made an informed decision.
Are there 401(k) fee benchmarking requirements?
There is no federal rule that says “benchmark every X years” or names a required report. The requirement is the duty itself: fiduciaries must act prudently and make sure the plan pays only reasonable fees for necessary services. Benchmarking is a practical way to carry out and document that duty.
What to benchmark
A useful fee benchmarking review breaks plan costs into their parts so each one can be compared on its own terms.
Recordkeeping and administration fees
These cover participant accounts, statements, the website and call center, payroll processing, testing, and government filings. They may be charged as a flat fee per participant, as a percentage of assets, or paid indirectly through revenue sharing from the funds. Convert each one to a common measure, such as total dollars per year and dollars per participant, so you can compare it with peers.
Advisory fees
If your plan works with an advisor, compare the advisory fee with the services provided: investment monitoring, investment policy statement support, committee meetings, employee education, and whether the advisor acts as a 3(21) or 3(38) investment fiduciary. Our guide to 3(21) vs. 3(38) fiduciaries explains the difference. Advisory fees are only comparable when the services behind them are.
Investment expense ratios
Fund expense ratios are often the largest cost in a plan, and participants usually pay them. Compare each fund’s expense ratio with similar funds in the same category, and check whether a lower-cost share class of the same fund is available to your plan. Note which funds pay revenue sharing and where that money goes. See our post on expense ratios for more background.
Services received
List what each provider actually does for the plan. Two plans with the same total cost can receive very different levels of service, so the services column matters as much as the fee column.
Other areas a retirement plan benchmarking review can cover
Many plan sponsors use the same review to look beyond fees:
- Investment performance: how each fund compares with its benchmark and peer group, measured against the criteria in your investment policy statement.
- Participation and deferral rates: enrollment trends, average deferral rates and employer contributions compared with similar plans.
- Plan design: features such as automatic enrollment, vesting schedules, loans and Roth options, compared with what similar plans offer.
- Service provider performance: the quality and responsiveness of your recordkeeper, administrator and advisor.
- Employee feedback: what participants say they need, which can shape education and communication.
How often should you benchmark 401(k) plan fees?
The DOL refers to reviews “at reasonable intervals” rather than a fixed schedule. Many plan sponsors review fees each year, often when they receive updated 408(b)(2) disclosures, and complete a more detailed benchmarking study every few years or when something changes.
Events that can call for a review sooner include:
- A significant change in plan assets or the number of participants.
- A change of recordkeeper, advisor or fund lineup.
- A provider announcing a fee increase or a change in services.
- Notice of a change in a provider’s compensation in a 408(b)(2) disclosure.
Whatever schedule you choose, write it down, for example in your committee charter or investment policy statement, and follow it.
How to use 408(b)(2) disclosures in benchmarking
Under the DOL’s 408(b)(2) regulation, covered service providers must give plan fiduciaries written information about the services they provide, their fiduciary status, and the direct and indirect compensation they expect to receive. Those disclosures are the starting point for any fee benchmarking review.
- Gather the current 408(b)(2) disclosure from each covered service provider: recordkeeper, advisor, third-party administrator and any others.
- List every fee, including indirect compensation such as revenue sharing, and note whether it is charged to the plan, to participants, or paid by the company.
- Convert the fees to common terms, such as total annual dollars, dollars per participant and percentage of plan assets.
- Match each fee to the services it pays for.
- Compare those figures with benchmarking data for plans of similar size and service level.
If you need a refresher on what these disclosures include, read our guide to 408(b)(2) and 404(a)(5) fee disclosures.
What to do with the benchmarking results
A benchmarking report is only useful if the committee acts on it. Depending on what the review shows, options include:
- Confirming the current arrangement. If fees are reasonable for the services received, record that conclusion and the reasons for it.
- Asking current providers to review their pricing or services, using the benchmarking data as context.
- Reviewing fund share classes or fund choices, consistent with your investment policy statement.
- Issuing a request for proposal (RFP) to compare other providers when the gap is significant or services fall short.
Reasonable doesn’t mean lowest. A decision to keep a higher-cost provider can be prudent when the services justify it, as long as the reasons are documented.
Documenting your benchmarking process
The DOL notes that documenting decisions and the basis for them is one of the ways fiduciaries can demonstrate that they carried out their responsibilities properly. For a fee benchmarking review, the file typically includes:
- The 408(b)(2) disclosures you reviewed.
- The benchmarking report or data used and the peer group it compared against.
- Committee meeting minutes showing the discussion, the decision and the reasons. Our post on investment committee responsibilities covers meeting records in more detail.
- Any follow-up actions, such as fee negotiations or an RFP, and their results.
- The date of the next scheduled review.
How we help
We work with plan sponsors as an advisor with a fiduciary standard. In a benchmarking review, we gather your 408(b)(2) disclosures, compare your plan’s recordkeeping, advisory and investment costs with those of similar plans, walk your committee through the results, and help you document the review and the decisions that follow.
FAQs
What is retirement plan benchmarking?
Retirement plan benchmarking compares a plan’s fees, services, investments and features with those of similar plans. It helps plan fiduciaries judge whether costs are reasonable for the services the plan receives.
How do I benchmark 401(k) plan fees?
Start with the 408(b)(2) disclosures from each service provider. List every direct and indirect fee, convert them to common terms such as dollars per participant and percentage of assets, match each fee to its services, and compare the results with data for plans of similar size. Then document the review and any decisions.
Is fee benchmarking required by law?
ERISA doesn’t require a specific benchmarking report. It does require fiduciaries to act prudently and to pay only reasonable plan expenses, and the DOL says fees should be monitored to determine whether they continue to be reasonable. Benchmarking is a common way to meet and document that duty.
How often should we benchmark our 401(k) fees?
The DOL calls for reviews at reasonable intervals. Many plan sponsors review fees annually and complete a more detailed study every few years or after a significant change in the plan.
How should we compare 401(k) benchmarking options?
Look at the peer group the data uses (plan size and number of participants), whether it separates recordkeeping, advisory and investment costs, whether it accounts for indirect compensation like revenue sharing, and whether it compares services as well as prices.
Does the lowest fee mean the plan is in better shape?
No. ERISA calls for reasonable fees, not the lowest fees. A plan can pay more and still be reasonable if it receives more services. What matters is that the fiduciaries understand the costs, compare them with the market and document why they made their decision.
Should we benchmark advisory fees separately?
Yes. Advisory fees should be compared with advisory services, such as investment monitoring, committee support, employee education and the advisor’s fiduciary role. Combining them with recordkeeping or investment costs makes the comparison harder to read.
Want a second look at your plan’s fees?
If it’s been a while since your plan’s fees were benchmarked, or you’re not sure how they compare with similar plans, we can walk through your disclosures with you and help you document the review.
Disclosures, Sources, and Footnotes
This information was developed as a general guide to educate plan sponsors, but is not intended as authoritative guidance or tax or legal advice. Each plan has unique requirements, and you should consult your attorney or tax advisor for guidance on your specific situation. In no way does advisor assure that, by using the information provided, plan sponsor will be in compliance with ERISA regulations.
Tracking #1201106

